The Last Centurion: Big Brother Takes Aim at Airline Miles

Insights from White Collar Criminal Defense Attorneys Trusted Nationwide

The Last Centurion: Big Brother Takes Aim at Airline Miles

Oh Jesus Pete.

The entity that can’t fix a road efficiently is investigating the last meritocracy in existence, your frequent flier miles.

“Points systems like frequent flyer miles and credit card rewards have become such a meaningful part of our economy that many Americans view their rewards points balances as part of their savings,” Pete Buttigieg has declared.

Buttigieg has decided to launch an inquiry into the sacred territory of the last great meritocracy in existence. I couldn’t think of a better use of Government power than the important constitutional government interest of “understanding”. Yes, I completely forgot about the episode of Schoolhouse Rock where the government can compel the production of documents to “understand”. I believe it was called “I’m just a highly regulated activity”.

Nonetheless, the Government sent document requests to the major airlines with the hope of unpacking “fairness” in the system.

 

Notwithstanding the complete departure from constitutional authority, why is this his job?

I’m clawing in the dark for an answer. But in sum, this isn’t about safety or transportation it’s about control – government control over a large sector of the economy. With findings comes a deferred prosecution agreement or a civil settlement and a corporate integrity agreement. These are the mechanisms of modern communism. Overregulate, find violations, insert control. Rinse and repeat.

To the average flyer, airline miles aren’t just points; they’re symbols of identity and status, like a nice dinner jacket. They’re what keep the dream of that business class upgrade or the free trip to Bali alive.

Buttigeig seeks to understand how one might get upgraded on a flight as if it's his duty to promote a fair country.

“How dare airlines change the value of miles without consulting us first?” he cries. It’s as if they’ve just discovered that airlines, like any business, might adjust their offerings based on, you know, business. Clearly, the government believes that the same people who can’t agree on what constitutes the appropriate amount of grains in my diet should now dictate how rewarding a mile should be.

The idea that government regulation could make airline miles more “fair” is like suggesting that by regulating how many marshmallows go into a Lucky Charms box, you’ll improve breakfast.

Nope, they failed at that too sanctioning FDA approved cereal killers.

 A balanced and nutritious diet of government fairness A balanced and nutritious diet of government fairness[/caption]

It’s not just about fairness; it’s about the absurdity of thinking they can control something as dynamic as consumer loyalty programs and that this control is better than capitalism and free choice.

It’s as if they’ve forgotten that airlines, like any business, thrive on customer satisfaction, not on the whims of bureaucratic meddling. Airlines are successful by appealing to their loyal customers. If Pete wants to have a say, fill out a comment card available here. We don’t need your help Pete.

So, here’s to the DOT, may your journey into the mystical realm of airline rewards be as fruitful as your other “good ideas”. We greatly appreciate your expenditure of resources in the sacred name of protecting us from evil airlines. Better yet, save my money and let me decide.

This article was brought to you by someone who’s more concerned about the government’s ability to regulate the air we breathe than how many miles they get for their next flight.

About the Author

Ronald Chapman II is the founder of Chapman, Dowling & Mallek and a top-rated Michigan federal criminal defense attorney who represents clients in federal courts nationwide. His practice is focused on defending individuals and organizations in complex federal prosecutions, including white-collar criminal matters and healthcare fraud investigations.

Throughout his career, Mr. Chapman has helped clients avoid more than $550 million in potential penalties, primarily in cases involving physicians, healthcare providers, executives, and professionals facing federal charges. He is widely recognized for his work as a Michigan healthcare fraud defense attorney, as well as for his results in white collar criminal defense in Michigan, where cases often involve parallel civil, regulatory, and criminal exposure.

Ronald Chapman II Federal criminal defense Attorney
3 Comments
Jason Kelly Jason Kelly September 6, 2024

It’s funny because miles or any kind of rewards points are just a return to you of some portion of the dollars that you spent. It’s not new money. It was yours to begin with.

Reply
Jessica Christy Jessica Christy September 6, 2024

Hey airlines… if you’re poor, just say that.

Reply
Ron Ron September 7, 2024

You had me rolling 😂😂.

Reply
Tags
Hospice Fraud Defense: CMS and Medicare Target Hospice in National Takedown

Apr-8-2026

Hospice Fraud Defense: CMS and Medicare Target Hospice in National Takedown

Hospice fraud is a serious enforcement priority for Medicare, and federal regulators are under pressure...

What Really Happens at a Federal Criminal Appeal? Inside a Recent Oral Argument

Apr-2-2026

What Really Happens at a Federal Criminal Appeal? Inside a Recent Oral Argument

In federal court, some of the most important battles happen after trial—on appeal—where the focus...

After Dismissal of the Most Serious Counts, Remaining FDA Criminal Charges Result in Mixed Verdict for Dr. Sanjeev Kumar

Jan-9-2026

After Dismissal of the Most Serious Counts, Remaining FDA Criminal Charges Result in Mixed Verdict for Dr. Sanjeev Kumar

Memphis, Tennessee – The verdict returned this week in United States v. Sanjeev Kumar closed...

Dr. Parker’s Pill Mill Case Reaches the Supreme Court: Implications for Healthcare & White Collar Criminal Defense

Dec-31-2025

Dr. Parker’s Pill Mill Case Reaches the Supreme Court: Implications for Healthcare & White Collar Criminal Defense

Dr. Lonnie Joseph Parker, a Texarkana physician, was recently convicted in federal court of unlawfully...

Headquartered in Detroit, Michigan

Serving Clients Nationwide.

Chapman, Dowling & Mallek is headquartered in Detroit, Michigan and represents clients in federal investigations and criminal matters across the United States. Our attorneys handle complex federal cases nationwide while maintaining offices in Michigan and other states.

456 E. Milwaukee, Detroit, MI 48202

See all Chapman, Dowling & Mallek office locations